19 Classic Cookie Recipes Ready for a Comeback on the Holiday Dessert Tray

Holiday dessert trays can start to look familiar when the same cookies return every year. This collection brings together old-school favorites, spiced bakes, fruit-filled treats, and a few playful twists, with textures ranging from crisp shortbread to soft, frosted cookies. Chocolate, citrus, pumpkin, and jam each have a place here. Choose a classic for a cookie swap or mix several styles to give the holiday tray more variety.

A close-up image shows a stack of four chocolate crinkle cookies covered in powdered sugar, revealing their cracked texture.
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies. Photo credit: Splash of Taste.

S’mores Stuffed Cookies

A close-up of chocolate chip cookies filled with melted marshmallow, with one cookie broken open to show the gooey center.
S’mores Stuffed Cookies. Photo credit: Your Perfect Recipes.

Golden edges and a gooey center give S’mores Stuffed Cookies their campfire-inspired character, with graham crackers, marshmallows, chocolate squares, and brown-butter dough in every batch. The recipe takes about 75 minutes and makes a dozen. Their familiar s’mores layers give a holiday cookie tray a playful change from standard drop cookies, and they travel well for a cookie exchange, too.
Get the Recipe: S’mores Stuffed Cookies

Pumpkin Oatmeal Cookies

A close-up of several oatmeal cookies stacked and scattered on parchment paper, with one cookie broken in half to show the inside texture.
Pumpkin Oatmeal Cookies. Photo credit: My Reliable Recipes.

Chewy texture and a soft middle make Pumpkin Oatmeal Cookies a seasonal pick for an afternoon coffee break. Pumpkin puree, rolled oats, maple syrup, cinnamon, and dried cranberries build their flavor and texture. The 12-cookie batch takes about 51 minutes, including chill time. Their pumpkin spice profile brings a familiar fall note to the holiday dessert tray without turning every choice into a frosted cookie.
Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Oatmeal Cookies

Tiramisu Cookies

A soft cookie topped with cream and cocoa powder has a bite taken out of it. Other similar cookies are visible in the background.
Tiramisu Cookies. Photo credit: My Reliable Recipes.

Coffeehouse notes meet a cookie-swap favorite in Tiramisu Cookies, which pair espresso in the dough with mascarpone cream and a dusting of cocoa. Butter, brown sugar, and powdered sugar round out the two parts. Fourteen cookies take about 37 minutes, with the topping added after baking. Their Italian-dessert flavor offers a different choice for a holiday tray beside the usual chocolate chip and sugar cookies.
Get the Recipe: Tiramisu Cookies

Soft Pumpkin Cookies With Pecans

Close-up of freshly baked cookies with nuts on top, arranged closely together.
Soft Pumpkin Cookies With Pecans. Photo credit: Pocket Friendly Recipes.

Tender centers and pecan crunch make Soft Pumpkin Cookies With Pecans a good match for a chilly afternoon. Pumpkin puree, brown sugar, butter, and pumpkin pie spice shape the soft dough, while chopped pecans add texture. The card lists about an hour total for 12 cookies, including chilling. Set them beside crisp or chocolate-heavy bakes to bring a gently spiced option to the holiday dessert tray.
Get the Recipe: Soft Pumpkin Cookies With Pecans

Thumb Print Cookie

Close-up of several stacks of thumbprint cookies filled with red jam, with one cookie in the foreground showing a bite taken out.
Thumb Print Cookie. Photo credit: Pocket Friendly Recipes.

Jewel-like jam centers give Thumb Print Cookie its recognizable look and a bright note among richer holiday bakes. The dough uses butter, sugar, egg yolks, vanilla, and flour, with strawberry or apricot jam pressed into each cookie. The recipe makes 12 in about 24 minutes. Their neat shape and colorful centers suit a dessert tray or cookie tin when you want a classic with a fruit finish.
Get the Recipe: Thumb Print Cookie

Lemon Cookies

A stack of lemon cookies on a cooling rack.
Lemon Cookies. Photo credit: Splash of Taste.

Citrus brings a lively edge to Lemon Cookies, balancing the richer chocolate and spice options on a holiday dessert tray. Fresh lemon zest is rubbed into sugar for the dough, and lemon juice and confectioners’ sugar make the glaze. The batch makes three dozen and takes about 29 minutes. Their soft, glazed finish makes them easy to portion for a swap, a party platter, or a small treat with coffee.
Get the Recipe: Lemon Cookies

Soft Thin Mint Chocolate Cookies

Close-up of Thin Mint Chocolate Cookies with green frosting and chocolate drizzle on top.
Soft Thin Mint Chocolate Cookies. Photo credit: Splash of Taste.

Cool mint and deep cocoa give Soft Thin Mint Chocolate Cookies a familiar candy-inspired flavor in a tender cookie form. Cocoa flavors the dough, while peppermint extract goes into the frosting and semisweet chocolate makes the drizzle. Sixteen cookies take about 55 minutes, including chill time. The green finish adds color to a holiday tray, and the mint-chocolate pairing stands apart from plain chocolate cookies.
Get the Recipe: Soft Thin Mint Chocolate Cookies

Cowboy Cookies

Two chocolate chip cookies with nuts stacked on top of each other in close-up view.
Cowboy Cookies. Photo credit: My Reliable Recipes.

Hearty and full of texture, Cowboy Cookies make an easy classic to bring back to a holiday tray. Old-fashioned oats, shredded coconut, chopped pecans, and semisweet chocolate chips join a brown-sugar dough with cinnamon. The 24-cookie batch takes about 32 minutes. Their generous mix-ins make them a substantial choice for a cookie exchange, especially when the rest of the platter leans toward small, delicate bakes.
Get the Recipe: Cowboy Cookies

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

A stack of chocolate chip cookies with a glass of milk.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies. Photo credit: Splash of Taste.

Soft centers and chocolate throughout put Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies in the running for a crowd-friendly holiday favorite. Smooth peanut butter is creamed into the dough with light brown sugar, butter, and chocolate chips. The recipe makes 24 cookies in about 22 minutes, with no chill time. Bring them to a swap when you want a familiar pairing that fits beside fruit, mint, or spiced choices.
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

Carrot Cake Cookies

A frosted cookie topped with chopped nuts has a bite taken out of it; other similar cookies are visible in the background.
Carrot Cake Cookies. Photo credit: Hungry Cooks Kitchen.

The flavor of a sliceable cake comes in a hand-held form with Carrot Cake Cookies. Shredded carrots, cinnamon, ginger, and chopped walnuts go into the dough, with cream cheese frosting tying the carrot-cake idea together. The recipe takes about 30 minutes and yields 20 cookies. Their warm spice and frosting make them a welcome choice for a dessert tray where most cookies are plain or chocolate-based.
Get the Recipe: Carrot Cake Cookies

Shortbread Cookies

Close-up view of a pile of Shortbread Cookies with visible small holes on the surface.
Shortbread Cookies. Photo credit: Hungry Cooks Kitchen.

Crisp edges and a buttery crumb give Shortbread Cookies their classic place on a holiday dessert tray. The six-ingredient dough combines butter, powdered sugar, flour, cornstarch, vanilla, and salt. Sixteen cookies take about 42 minutes. Their simple flavor gives the platter a break between fruit, frosting, and chocolate, and the cookies can be packed into a tin for sharing or gifting.
Get the Recipe: Shortbread Cookies

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

A close-up of several chocolate chip cookies on parchment paper, with one cookie broken in half to show the chocolate chips inside.
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies. Photo credit: Your Perfect Recipes.

Fall spice and pockets of chocolate make Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies a natural addition to the holiday baking lineup. The dough combines drained pumpkin puree, browned butter, pumpkin spice, brown sugar, and chocolate chips for a soft, chewy finish. Allow about 101 minutes for a dozen, including cooling and chilling steps. Make them when the tray needs a pumpkin option with familiar chocolate-chip appeal.
Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

Strawberry Cookies

Stacks of strawberry cookies, one with a bite taken out, are arranged next to a glass of milk and whole strawberries.
Strawberry Cookies. Photo credit: Splash of Taste.

Pink color and a fruity aroma help Strawberry Cookies brighten a holiday dessert tray filled with browns and golds. Freeze-dried strawberry powder and pieces flavor a butter-based dough, with flour, sugar, and vanilla holding the batch together. Twenty-four cookies take about 32 minutes. Their berry flavor offers a lighter contrast to chocolate and spice, giving swap guests several flavors to choose from.
Get the Recipe: Strawberry Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookies

A hand holding a chocolate chip cookie on a cooling rack.
Chocolate Chip Cookies. Photo credit: Splash of Taste.

No holiday cookie tray feels complete without a familiar batch, and Chocolate Chip Cookies bring that classic choice. Butter, white and brown sugars, vanilla, eggs, and chocolate chips form a soft, chewy cookie. The recipe takes about 20 minutes and makes 36 cookies. Bake them for a large swap or family dessert spread, where an everyday favorite can balance more unusual flavors like tiramisu or mint.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Chip Cookies

Spiced Apple Cookies

Close-up of three stacked cookies topped with a chunky fruit filling and a sprinkle of crumbs, placed near an apple.
Spiced Apple Cookies. Photo credit: Hungry Cooks Kitchen.

Hidden beneath a cinnamon-sugar finish, Spiced Apple Cookies have a sweet fruit center that gives each one a little surprise. Diced apple cooks with brown sugar, butter, cinnamon, and water before being tucked into the cookie dough. The recipe takes about 95 minutes and makes nine, with resting time counted. Their fruit-and-spice combination brings the flavor of an apple bake to the tray in a cookie-sized portion.
Get the Recipe: Spiced Apple Cookies

Peanut Butter Cookies

Close-up of a classic peanut butter cookie with the iconic crisscross pattern on top, nestled among a delightful batch of similar peanut butter cookies.
Peanut Butter Cookies. Photo credit: Splash of Taste.

Fork-marked tops and a soft center make Peanut Butter Cookies an old-school pick for holiday sharing. Crunchy peanut butter, brown sugar, butter, and flour create the dough, while a crisscross pattern gives each cookie its familiar finish. Twelve cookies take about 26 minutes, and the dough can be baked without chilling. Add them when the dessert tray needs a straightforward peanut-butter option beside chocolate or fruit.
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Cookies

Chocolate Cherry Cookies

Enjoy our chocolate cherry cookies, each topped with a swirl of rich chocolate frosting and a vibrant red cherry.
Chocolate Cherry Cookies. Photo credit: My Reliable Recipes.

Old-fashioned dessert charm comes through in Chocolate Cherry Cookies, with a cherry tucked into each center. Cocoa, maraschino cherries, semisweet chocolate chips, and sweetened condensed milk build the chocolate-forward recipe. Sixteen cookies take about 20 minutes. Their dark color and cherry centers add variety to a platter of pale shortbread, fruit cookies, and familiar drop-cookie shapes at a holiday swap.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Cherry Cookies

Banana Pudding Cookies

A stack of white chocolate chip cookies with a bite taken out of the top one, placed on a cooling rack with a banana and peeled banana in the background.
Banana Pudding Cookies. Photo credit: Hungry Cooks Kitchen.

Dessert-counter nostalgia and a soft texture make Banana Pudding Cookies a playful addition to a holiday cookie spread. Mashed ripe banana and banana pudding mix flavor the dough, while white chocolate chips add creamy sweetness. The recipe takes about 27 minutes and yields 18 cookies. Bring them to a gathering when you want something recognizable but different from the usual chocolate, spice, and jam-centered choices.
Get the Recipe: Banana Pudding Cookies

Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

A close-up image shows a stack of four chocolate crinkle cookies covered in powdered sugar, revealing their cracked texture.
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies. Photo credit: Splash of Taste.

Cracked white tops over fudgy centers make Chocolate Crinkle Cookies one of the most recognizable holiday bakes. Cocoa and vegetable oil form the chocolate dough, which gets rolled in confectioners’ sugar before baking. The full recipe takes about 4 hours and 27 minutes, including a long chill, and yields 24. Prepare the dough ahead for a cookie exchange, then bake a tray with its signature powdered finish.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *